Review: "Story of a Girl" by Sara Zarr

Sara Zarr’s 2007 novel, Story of a Girl is a classic story of the consequences of teenage lust, gossip, and social isolation.  Deanna wrestles with her tarnished reputation after her father catches her having sex while stoned with a high school senior, Tommy, when she was just 13. Even three years after this mortifying incident, Deanna, now 16, finds herself socially ostracized and labeled as a slut – especially by her father. While she still has two friends left, Jason (with whom she is slightly in love) and his girlfriend, Lee, she continues to struggle with feelings of isolation. Deanna is forced to deal with her past when she takes a job at a local pizza place where Tommy happens to work. While her family appears to unravel in many ways, Deanna ultimately sets herself free by accepting her actions, forgiving Tommy, and reaching out to repair her relationship with her father.

While the novel may appear slightly formulaic at first glance in terms of plot, there are some notable points of interest that make Story of a Girl an interesting and enjoyable read. For one, Deanna seems to articulate the experience of any girl who has had nasty rumours spread about her through a first-person narrative with her sarcasm and occasional wit. Zarr also uses flashbacks to Deanna’s childhood, where she reminisces about her innocence and her positive, close relationship with her parents, effectively juxtaposing her current situation. Feelings of guilt and a real yearning for her childhood are certainly relatable for most teens struggling with growing up or coming to terms with past lapses in judgment. The journal she keeps effectively shows a progression of her escaping intense self-loathing, and finding closure. Another important theme of the novel is that of double standards of sexuality for boys and girls. While Deanna is judged as being promiscuous, Tommy is seen as masculine and suffers no consequences for his sexual escapades.

Since this novel is character-driven, the plot tends to drag. However, through these moments, the reader gains valuable information on the development of the major characters. Considering the subject matter (and taking into account the gendered differences described above), this novel would appeal primarily to girls. Still, the prose is excellent and makes for a very enjoyable read.

Rating: 4Q 4P S